House impeachment team adviser and spokesperson Robert Ace Barbers has rejected allegations that criminal charges against individual senator-judges were fabricated by the administration to prevent them from participating in Vice President Sara Z. Duterte’s Senate impeachment trial.
Barbers responded to claims that these legal actions were designed to lower the total number of votes needed to secure a conviction by reducing the voting denominator. He stressed that pending legal cases involving lawmakers are based on independent facts and evidence rather than a coordinated strategy to influence the proceedings.
“All these things are not fabricated. Parang sinisisi pa ’yung gobyerno na kaya merong mga kasong ganito, eh dahil inimbento against you,” Barbers stated during an online press briefing.
The former Surigao del Norte representative addressed concerns raised by Duterte’s defense team regarding potential changes to the voting rules. Duterte spokesperson Salvador Paolo Panelo Jr. had warned that departing from the current 16-vote standard could create an incentive for those in power to target senators expected to vote for acquittal.
The issue has come to the fore because several senator-judges are unable to attend the trial. Among them is Sen. Rodante Marcoleta, who is currently detained while contesting a P75-million plunder case linked to campaign donations received during the 2025 elections. Marcoleta has denied the charges and is seeking bail.
Citing Marcoleta’s situation, Barbers dismissed assertions that the executive branch manufactured charges to alter the Senate court’s makeup. He maintained that any questions surrounding the legitimacy of an indictment should be evaluated through the judicial process.
“Magpaliwanag kayo, harapin iyong kaso,” Barbers said.
The debate over member participation coincides with a challenge to Presiding Officer Senator Francis Escudero’s ruling that a conviction requires 16 votes, representing two-thirds of the full 24-member Senate.
Following a motion for reconsideration filed by Senator Erwin Tulfo, the impeachment court requested input from four retired Supreme Court justices to clarify how the denominator should be calculated.
Retired Chief Justices Artemio Panganiban, Reynato Puno, and Hilario Davide Jr. suggested that the denominator could adjust based on a senator’s legal standing or physical capacity to participate. Meanwhile, retired Associate Justice Adolfo Azcuna maintained that the threshold must remain based on all 24 sitting senators.
The House prosecution and Duterte’s defense team are set to present their oral arguments on the threshold calculation on September 23.
Barbers emphasized that prosecutors are focused on presenting their evidence rather than calculating vote thresholds. The prosecution is currently introducing evidence under Article II regarding alleged unexplained wealth, having already completed presentations for Article I on confidential funds and Article IV on alleged grave threats. Presentation of evidence for Article III, which covers bribery allegations, remains pending.



